2024 Range Hood Comparison | HKELE

Posted System 01/01/2024 0 Comment(s) How to choose appliances,Tips for using appliances,Latest News,

2024 Range Hood Comparison and Recommendations (Test Results from Consumer Council Included)


2024 Range Hood Comparison and Recommendations (Test Results from Consumer Council Included)

Click the following links for quick navigation through the article:


Which Range Hood Is the Best? Key Points for Purchasing a Range Hood in 2024


Cooking fumes not only makes the kitchen dirty but inhaling them can cause respiratory diseases. According to some studies, long-term inhalation of cooking fumes may even lead to cancer. In Hong Kong, people particularly like to cook fried foods and emphasize the "wok hei" (smoky flavors and aromas), which produces more fumes. At this point, the importance of a range hood becomes apparent. A range hood is an essential appliance in every Hong Kong kitchen. However, many BBE customers know little about range hoods and are clueless about where to start when selecting the right one. Here, BBE compares the advantages and disadvantages of different range hoods and delivers installation tips to help you better understand the various criteria to consider when selecting a range hood.


1. Comparison of Range Hood Types


Range hoods can be divided into three types based on their principle: recirculating, exhaust, and combined.


Ducted Range Hoods:


Suitable only for a portion of homes in Hong Kong. These range hoods must be installed with an exhaust pipe, and their operating principle is to suck the fumes into the hood and then expel them outdoors through the exhaust pipe. This method effectively removes fumes and even the hot air in the kitchen, keeping the kitchen or indoors fresh. However, the downside is that an exhaust hole must be installed in the wall or window to bring in fresh air continuously. In the past, these range hoods were equipped with oil filters to remove the grease, but now, many use oil collecting cups to maintain efficiency. For users who often cook with high heat, emphasizing "wok hei," or like to cook strongly flavored dishes, ducted range hoods are more suitable.




Expels odors, grease, and hot air directly

May not be compatible with some kitchens that lack exhaust holes due to structure (e.g., range hood is not situated near a window) or space constraints

Reduces noise levels

Has a higher initial cost, such as for ductwork and installation fees

Does not require regular replacement of activated carbon filters, making long-term operational costs cheaper

Causes loss of heat in winter and loss of cool air in summer

Has higher air flow rate, i.e., more efficient suction and filtering, due to the absence of filters

Brings in fresh air continuously while expelling hot air from the kitchen


Recirculating Range Hoods:

As recirculating range hoods do not require an exhaust hole, all Hong Kong kitchens can install them theoretically. These range hoods filter cooking fumes through two layers of filters. First, the fumes pass through an outer oil filter, then through an inner activated carbon filter. The air, purified by the two filters, is then expelled back into the kitchen. If your kitchen has no exhaust hole, you can choose this type of range hood. Recirculating range hoods are also suitable if your family mostly cooks with low heat, producing less smoke and smell through steaming and boiling. However, the efficiency of recirculating range hoods is closely related to the efficiency of the "purification" of the carbon filter. Filters with proper thickness, activeness, and dense structure have better filtering effects.




Easy to install

Needs regular replacement of filters every few months to half a year, depending on usage, indirectly increasing long-term operational costs

Does not require special installation of exhaust ducts, can be installed in any kitchen

Has lower initial cost due to absence of ductwork

Cannot introduce fresh air and expel hot air from the kitchen

Retains heat in winter and preserves cool air in summer


Integrated Range Hoods:

The third type is the integrated range hood, which has the features of both ducted and recirculating types. However, this does not mean it operates with principles simultaneously. You must decide which extraction principle to use during installation. If you install an exhaust pipe, the technician will remove the carbon filter, and the range hood becomes a ducted type. Conversely, if you do not install an exhaust pipe, it becomes a recirculating range hood.



2. Range Hood Sizes


The second most common factor to consider is the size of the range hood, and the most direct answer is to refer to the surface area of your stove. The range hood does not necessarily have to match the exact area of your stove, but if you want to absorb most of the cooking fumes accurately, the size of your range hood should at least cover the entire stove surface. Of course, the larger the range hood, the more expensive it will be, but if you already use a large stove, it is definitely worth complementing it with a larger range hood. If your stove has three burners, you can choose a range hood with a width of about 120 cm, and if only two, then a 90 cm model would be suitable. Generally, the most common range hood size is 90 cm, followed by smaller models of 70 cm and 60 cm.


3. Range Hood Suction Power

After understanding the operating principle and size of range hoods, the exhaust airflow is another key point in comparing range hoods. The main purpose of buying a range hood is to remove fumes to lessen its impact on our health. To accurately understand the suction power of a range hood, we can estimate it using "exhaust airflow." Although manufacturers do not have a universal standard for measuring exhaust airflow, its specification is the most valuable data on suction power you should consider. Many Hong Kong people's favorite Chinese cuisine requires high heat for stir-frying, and range hoods with high exhaust airflow can help you remove most fumes. If you have a large household, or if your family members particularly like to cook fried and stir-fried foods, you should choose a range hood model with an exhaust airflow rate of about 1,000 cubic meters per hour (about 17 cubic meters per minute) or more. If there are fewer family members, or if you cook Western-style dishes that produce fewer fumes, you can choose models with an exhaust airflow of about 800 cubic meters per hour (about 16 cubic meters per minute). You can purchase a range hood with an appropriate exhaust volume based on your actual situation. However, take note that although a higher exhaust airflow can expel more fumes, it also consumes more electricity.


Another reference data is the fan speed. Models with a fan speed of 1300 RPM (revolutions per minute) or more have an ideal fume extraction effect, and some models can even reach up to 3000 RPM. However, fan speed is directly related to its motor, and the motor speed directly affects the noise range produced during operation. You can also visit BBE's stores in Mong Kok, Causeway Bay, and Tuen Mun to test the machine directly and observe whether its noise range is appropriate.


4. Range Hood Materials

Range hoods are primarily made of stainless steel and enamel. In terms of cost, enamel and stainless steel range hoods are more common and affordable. When it comes to cleaning, the enamel and stainless steel surfaces are very easy to cleanse. After all, the main function of a range hood is to expel the fumes generated during cooking. As the fumes are expelled, the body of the machine itself will also be stained with grease and dirt. Basically, after cooking, users will usually wipe the grease off its surface, and before the New Year, they can thoroughly clean it, using a detergent to clean the range hood. The surface of enamel-coated range hoods is more susceptible to corrosion by cleaning agents, while stainless steel surfaces do not have this problem.


5. Range Hood Appearance


In addition to size, suction power, and materials, the appearance of the range hood is also part of the consumer's consideration. Range hood appearances can be roughly divided into six types: traditional Chinese wall-mounted type, inclined chimney type, deep hood type, European-style funnel type, inverted T type, and built-in type.


  • Traditional Wall-Mounted Type: Currently the most popular model with the lowest price and average suction power.
  • Inclined Chimney Type: An improved version of the standard model, the inner wall and inclined back design on both sides can more effectively concentrate fumes with a better smoke collection effect than the standard model.
  • Deep Hood Type: The hood is thicker than the standard model, like a higher hood, and improves the fume-collecting effect through a larger fume-collecting chamber.
  • Funnel Type: It has a one-piece design with beautiful lines and texture. Without considering its motor capacity and purely in terms of design, it has the best suction power among European-style range hoods.
  • Inverted T Type: Minimalist design, sleek and stylish.
  • Telescopic and Built-in Type: It can be embedded in cabinets. Only a thin piece of metal is visible when not in use, and the air vent needs to be pulled out when in use. This type is highly recommended for those who value overall kitchen design.


6. Cleaning the Range Hood

The primary function of a range hood is to extract cooking fumes, making it one of the kitchen appliances that accumulate the most grease. How to choose the right material, filters, and features to maintain it is a key consideration for cooks. As mentioned earlier, range hoods are typically made of stainless steel or enamel. Stainless steel is durable, easy to clean, and resistant to scratches, while enamel looks attractive but is less durable and should be wiped with a soft cloth.


Secondly, range hoods need to be equipped with filters or exhaust hoods. On one hand, this helps to filter the fumes and prevents grease from sticking to the internal blades, affecting the suction power and ensuring the expelled air is cleaner. On the other hand, it prevents hair and other foreign objects from being sucked in, which could cause injury to the user. Filters can accumulate a lot of grease, and imported range hoods usually have three to five layers of oil filters at the air vent, which are easy to dismantle and can be directly cleaned in a dishwasher. Many manufacturers have developed different range hoods with automatic cleaning functions to make it convenient for users. BBE offers a wide selection of these, some of which are exclusive models.


7. Control Panel of the Range Hood

When buying a range hood, it's recommended to choose a range hood with the control panel installed on the front. Also, pay attention to the different signs and functions on the control panel.

  • Stove Lighting Button: This touch button can turn the lighting on or off and adjust its brightness.
  • Exhaust Fan Switch: Besides turning the exhaust fan on and off, most range hoods allow you to choose the fan strength and whether it continues to run. The fan can be set to continue running and then automatically turn off after 5 or 10 minutes.
  • Oil Filter Control: The indicator light will illuminate when the oil filter needs cleaning. Some range hoods use this button to reset the usage time calculator after each filter cleaning. It can also be used to check or change the filter.


Key Takeaways from the Consumer Council's Range Hood Test Report


Range Hood Safety Standard Test


The Consumer Council noted that several range hoods' bottom plates, fan covers, rectifiers, and/or filters when opened, allowed fingers to touch the fan blades during testing, which does not meet safety standards. This includes "Fujioh FR-FS1870V SM," "German Pool WRZ-723," "Sakura SR-2883S," "White-Westinghouse WHH28DS," "Zanussi ZHT900X," "Athens GH-268 IEC," and "Taada GR7101PS."


Additionally, three range hoods had encountered electrical safety issues, including "German Pool WRZ-723" and "Athens GH-268 IEC." For the German Pool sample, when the power plug was pulled out from the socket, the voltage between the plug pins exceeded the upper limit of the standard requirements after 1 second. The Consumer Council reminds users not to touch the plug pins immediately after unplugging. For the Athens sample, when the bottom plate was opened, it exposed users to partially unprotected internal areas. Furthermore, the Consumer Council's tests simulated abnormal operation of these range hood samples, such as locking the motor shaft inside the sample, causing internal strain. Upon checking the sample, they found that the "Taada GR7101PS" sample started smoking after about 20 minutes of abnormal operation, increasing the fire risk.


Range Hood Noise Test


The Consumer Council measured the sound power levels of 15 range hood samples ranging from 64 to 73 decibels. To put it in perspective, the noise produced by these range hoods during operation is comparable to those in the street environment. The performance of these four major types of range hoods varied among the samples. The "TGC EXCEL 710" (a chimney style hood) and the "Philco GH1206S" (a sliding type hood) were the quietest, both measuring 64 decibels. Meanwhile, the chimney style "Pacific PR6108-U70S", baffle filter style "German Pool WRZ-723", and traditional dual fan hoods "Simpa STR723DS" and "Taada GR7101PS" ranged between 72 to 73 decibels.


Range Hood Rating Results




Chimney Style Range Hoods


Whirlpool AKR4071/IX


Panasonic FV-953P




Pacific PR6108-U70S


Sliding Type Range Hoods


Electrolux EFP60473OS


Philco GH1206S


Baffle Filter Style Range Hoods


Fujioh FR-FS1870V SM


German Pool WRZ-723


Traditional Dual Fan Range Hoods


Siemens LU83S750HK


Sakura SR-2883S


Simpa STR723DS


White-Westinghouse WHH28DS


Zanussi ZHT900X


Athens GH-268 IEC


Taada GR7101PS



Source: https://www.weekendhk.com/1001543/lifestyle/%e5%a5%bd%e7%94%9f%e6%b4%bb%e7%99%be%e7%a7%91/%e6%8a%bd%e6%b2%b9%e7%85%99%e6%a9%9f-%e6%b6%88%e5%a7%94%e6%9c%83-%e6%b8%ac%e8%a9%a6-%e5%ae%89%e5%85%a8-%e4%bf%


2024 Top 6 High-Rated Range Hood Brands and Models

Here are the top 6 high-rated range hood brands and models recommended by the Consumer Council in 2023:

Recommended Chimney Style Range Hood: ELECTROLUX EFC926SA

Features of this model:
Air extraction volume up to 1140 cubic meters per hour
Oil cup design
Easy to clean
Strong suction power
Quiet design

Recommended Chimney Style Range Hood: Siemens LC91BUR50B 90CM

Features of this model:
Siemens patented iQDrive motor with up to ten years of warranty
Equipped with 3 baffle filters that can be cleaned in a dishwasher
Optional accessories include:
- cleanAir recirculation air kit
- Activated carbon air filter kit

Recommended Ducted Range Hood: ATHENS IM8990 90CM

Features of this model:
Strengthened black glass design on the baffle
Elegant and technologically modern style
High air extraction volume of up to 1200 cubic meters per hour, instantly removing grease and smoke
Easy to dismantle the flow guide for filter replacement and cleaning, saving time and effort

Recommended Ducted Range Hood: ATHENS VM-7288 70CM​

Features of this model:
70 cm width suitable for smaller kitchens
Built-in oil collecting cup design that does not require washing
High air extraction volume of up to 1200 cubic meters per hour, instantly removing grease and smoke

Recommended Angled Range Hood: FUJIOH FR-SC2090P SM 90CM

Features of this model:
Available in 4 colors
Oil-resistant coating on the body
Baffle filter
Streamlined slanted design

Chimney Style Range Hood (Consumer Council Recommendation No. 3): WHIRLPOOL AKR4071/IX 76CM​

Features of this model:
Rated No. 1 by the Consumer Council
Air extraction volume: 1000 cubic meters per hour
3 cm slim panel design
Sleek and elegant appearance


Installation Precautions for Range Hoods

When installing a range hood, the following points should be noted to ensure safety and effectiveness:
  • The range hood should ideally be installed directly above the stove to effectively capture all the smoke and fumes that rise while cooking.
  • A minimum distance of 65 centimeters should be maintained between a gas stove and the range hood, and at least 55 centimeters for an induction stove to prevent fire hazards during cooking.
  • However, if the range hood is installed too high above the stove, it may affect its ability to extract smoke effectively.
  • For ducted range hoods, consider the bends in the exhaust pipe and whether a long pipe is needed to reach the window.
  • The exhaust duct should be as straight and short as possible for optimal performance. If the duct is too long and has many bends, it may not ventilate efficiently.


Tips for Using and Maintaining Range Hoods

To maintain good performance and extend the lifespan of the range hood, consider the following tips:
  • Continue running the range hood for about 10 minutes after cooking to remove any residual smoke and odors from the kitchen thoroughly.
  • Do not move cooking pots on the stove while cooking to prevent any flames from being drawn into the range hood, which can be dangerous.
  • For range hoods with oil filters, regularly clean or replace the filters to prevent excessive oil accumulation.
  • Experts recommend cleaning the filters with hot water and detergent every 10-15 days and replacing the entire oil filter every three months.
  • For circulating range hoods with activated carbon filters, which cannot be cleaned, replacing the filters every 6-9 months is recommended.
  • For range hoods with oil collectors, regularly empty and clean them to prevent oil spillage.


Shopping Tips: What to Know When Choosing a Ducted Range Hood

The information above is essential when choosing a fume extractor hood. Apart from considering the exhaust airflow and the noise produced, we have also summarized several points to note during the installation, use, and maintenance of the range hood. BBE provides a comprehensive service for delivering and installing ducted range hoods. Our professional technicians will determine the appropriate installation location based on the manufacturer's instructions and your home environment. We also offer expert advice and competitive pricing on ducted range hoods. If you have any questions about purchasing a ducted range hood, feel free to contact us or visit our stores located in Mong Kok, Causeway Bay, and Tuen Mun for a consultation with our professional appliance consultants.





Leave a Comment